History 326 Readings Wiki

User Tools

Site Tools

Trace: • horton_freedom_s_yoke • gilfoyle_city_of_eros • black_dismantling_black_manhood • romero_making_war_and_minting_christians • dorsey_making_men_what_they_should_be • johansen_family_men
mccurdy_gentlemen_and_soldiers

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision		Previous revision
mccurdy_gentlemen_and_soldiers [2026/01/23 15:23] – 199.111.65.35mccurdy_gentlemen_and_soldiers [2026/01/23 21:51] (current) – jjardine
Line 4: Line 4:
  
 The discussion of gentlemen and soldiers shows how manhood was defined through honor, discipline, and public reputation rather than purely physical strength. The reading contextualizes masculinity as a social performance shaped by class and military service, where gentlemanly restraint and soldierly courage both upheld authority and civic order. This framework reveals how early American society used ideals of manliness to legitimize power, hierarchy, and political participation.-- (Caitlyn Edwards) The discussion of gentlemen and soldiers shows how manhood was defined through honor, discipline, and public reputation rather than purely physical strength. The reading contextualizes masculinity as a social performance shaped by class and military service, where gentlemanly restraint and soldierly courage both upheld authority and civic order. This framework reveals how early American society used ideals of manliness to legitimize power, hierarchy, and political participation.-- (Caitlyn Edwards)
 +
 +The examination of British hierarchical structure and it's unique relationship to both social status and Military service allows for further understanding of the shifting social dynamics present both in later England and in the Jamestown colony. Seeing the norms surrounding manhood and status be challenged by the lack of structure in the colony serves as an excellent insight into how norms shift when strained by scarcity both in resources and social structure. ( J.D.J. )
  
 ===== Military Manhood ===== ===== Military Manhood =====
Line 29: Line 31:
  
 McCurdy argues that Jamestown's instability did not simply stem from the environmental conflict the settlers faced, but mostly from the conflicting definitions of manhood. Higher-class settlers saw their masculinity rooted in birth and status, while lower-class settlers saw the military as their way to manhood through physical strength and skill. This made it difficult for the men to decide and appoint a leader, which led to mutiny and was a large factor in the failures of the colony. (Callie McAleese)  McCurdy argues that Jamestown's instability did not simply stem from the environmental conflict the settlers faced, but mostly from the conflicting definitions of manhood. Higher-class settlers saw their masculinity rooted in birth and status, while lower-class settlers saw the military as their way to manhood through physical strength and skill. This made it difficult for the men to decide and appoint a leader, which led to mutiny and was a large factor in the failures of the colony. (Callie McAleese) 
 +
 +The unique conditions presented by Jamestown with both it's geographic location as well as the period of time in which it was founded created an environment that constantly challenged the notions of "Manhood" that figures like George Percy and even John Smith tried to implement through their leadership. Keeping these conditions in mind allows us to better understand the foundations of manhood that survive through the constant stressing of colonial ideals. ( Jonathan Jardines )
  
mccurdy_gentlemen_and_soldiers.1769181802.txt.gz · Last modified: by 199.111.65.35